"""Raw-only, scene-paired attribution statistics; no media/model/optimizer access.""" from collections import defaultdict import numpy as np METRICS = ( "depth_absrel", "depth_rmse", "depth_delta1", "rgb_mse", "rgb_ssim", "opacity", "coverage", ) GEOMETRY = ("insideGTfraction", "ray_hitfraction", "GTdistance_above_far_fraction") CURRENT = "CURRENT_BOUNDS" ALTERNATIVE = "PREDECLARED_GEOMETRY_BOUNDS" TIE = 1e-8 def group_key(track, grid=8, samples=64, bounds=CURRENT, method="direct"): return f"{track}|g{grid}|s{samples}|{bounds}|{method}" def row_key(row): return group_key(row["track"], row["grid"], row["samples"], row["bounds_mode"], row["method"]) def describe(values, *, draws=10000, seed=20260927, positive_means_improvement=False): """Resample complete paired scene values, never queries or contexts.""" ids = sorted(values) x = np.asarray([values[s] for s in ids], dtype=float) if not len(x) or not np.isfinite(x).all(): raise ValueError("Nonempty finite scene values required") index = np.random.default_rng(seed).integers(0, len(x), (draws, len(x))) ci = np.percentile(x[index].mean(axis=1), [2.5, 97.5]).tolist() positive = np.maximum(x, 0) absolute = np.abs(x) def share(v, n): return float(np.sort(v)[-n:].sum() / v.sum()) if v.sum() else None loso = {s: float(np.delete(x, i).mean()) for i, s in enumerate(ids)} if len(x) > 1 else {} result = { "n_scenes": len(ids), "per_scene": dict(zip(ids, x.tolist(), strict=True)), "mean": float(x.mean()), "median": float(np.median(x)), "ci95": ci, "loso": loso, "loso_range": [min(loso.values()), max(loso.values())] if loso else None, "positive": int((x > TIE).sum()), "tied": int((np.abs(x) <= TIE).sum()), "negative": int((x < -TIE).sum()), "positive_top1_contribution": share(positive, 1), "positive_top3_contribution": share(positive, 3), "absolute_top1_contribution": share(absolute, 1), "absolute_top3_contribution": share(absolute, 3), "bootstrap": {"unit": "scene", "draws": draws, "seed": seed, "CI": "percentile95"}, } if positive_means_improvement: result["improved_tied_worse"] = [result["positive"], result["tied"], result["negative"]] return result def scene_values(rows, metric): """Each role has equal weight regardless of its number of scored frames.""" role_values = defaultdict(list) for row in rows: value = row.get(metric) if value is None or not np.isfinite(value): raise ValueError(f"Missing or nonfinite {metric}; cannot silently discard a scene") role_values[row["scene_id"], row.get("role", "joint")].append(float(value)) scenes = defaultdict(list) for (scene, _), values in role_values.items(): scenes[scene].append(float(np.mean(values))) return {scene: float(np.mean(values)) for scene, values in sorted(scenes.items())} def paired(left, right, *, draws=10000, seed=20260927, improvement=True): if not left or set(left) != set(right): raise ValueError("Paired comparisons require identical complete scene sets") return describe( {s: left[s] - right[s] for s in left}, draws=draws, seed=seed, positive_means_improvement=improvement, ) def stable_gain(stats): return ( stats["mean"] >= 0.02 and stats["ci95"][0] > 0 and (stats["positive"] + stats["tied"]) / stats["n_scenes"] >= 0.75 ) def engineering_good(stats): return ( stats["mean"] <= 0.25 and np.mean(np.asarray(list(stats["per_scene"].values())) <= 0.35) >= 0.75 ) def classify(groups, comparisons): """Frozen engineering thresholds; evidence is not a causal decomposition.""" rgbd = groups[group_key("RGBD")]["metrics"]["depth_absrel"] rgbonly = groups[group_key("RGB_ONLY")]["metrics"]["depth_absrel"] oracle = groups[group_key("QUERY_ORACLE")]["metrics"]["depth_absrel"] resolution = [comparisons[f"resolution_RGBD_{a}_to_{b}"] for a, b in [(8, 16), (16, 32)]] render = [comparisons[f"renderer_RGBD_g{g}_64_to_128"] for g in (8, 16)] stable_render = [s["mean"] for s in render if stable_gain(s)] flags = { "LEARNER_TRAINING_BOTTLENECK": bool( engineering_good(rgbonly) and stable_gain(comparisons["capacity_gap_RGB_ONLY_g8"]) ), "CONTEXT_INFERENCE_BOTTLENECK": bool( engineering_good(oracle) and stable_gain(comparisons["context_RGBD_minus_oracle_g8"]) ), "RESOLUTION_BOTTLENECK": any(stable_gain(s) for s in resolution), "RENDERER_BOTTLENECK": bool( stable_render and max(stable_render) > max(s["mean"] for s in resolution) ), } sufficient = bool( engineering_good(rgbd) and stable_gain(comparisons["capacity_gap_RGBD_g8"]) and stable_gain(comparisons["anchor_gap_RGBD_g8"]) ) names = { "LEARNER_TRAINING_BOTTLENECK": "LEARNER_LIMITED", "CONTEXT_INFERENCE_BOTTLENECK": "CONTEXT_INFERENCE_LIMITED", "RESOLUTION_BOTTLENECK": "RESOLUTION_LIMITED", "RENDERER_BOTTLENECK": "RENDERER_LIMITED", } active = [k for k, v in flags.items() if v] status = ( "MIXED" if len(active) > 1 else names[active[0]] if active else ("SUFFICIENT" if sufficient else "INCONCLUSIVE") ) recommendations = [] if flags["LEARNER_TRAINING_BOTTLENECK"]: recommendations.append( "Design a separate matched carrier retraining protocol; do not train now" ) if flags["CONTEXT_INFERENCE_BOTTLENECK"]: recommendations.append( "Study context lifting, information and inverse-problem optimization" ) if flags["RESOLUTION_BOTTLENECK"]: recommendations.append( "Design a separate higher-resolution carrier study with optimization controls" ) if flags["RENDERER_BOTTLENECK"]: recommendations.append( "Study ray integration resolution separately from state construction" ) if not recommendations: recommendations.append( "Resolve finite-optimization and bounds ambiguity before new carrier training" ) return { "STATE_CAPACITY_STATUS": status, "next_stage_recommendations_only": recommendations, "NEW_CARRIER_TRAINED": False, "FINAL_HOLDOUT_TOUCHED": False, "DYNAMIC_TTT_RUN": False, **flags, "REPRESENTATION_BOTTLENECK": "NOT_ESTABLISHED_BY_FINITE_OPTIMIZATION", "sufficient_rgbd_evidence": sufficient, "engineering_good": { "RGBD8": bool(engineering_good(rgbd)), "RGB_ONLY8": bool(engineering_good(rgbonly)), "QUERY_ORACLE8": bool(engineering_good(oracle)), }, "renderer_comparison_rule": ( "largest stable renderer mean gain > largest RGBD grid mean gain" ), "limitations": [ "Exposed attribution scenes, not independent qualification", "RGBD depth is privileged; this gap alone cannot identify RGB-only learner failure", "Finite optimization and bounds limitations preclude proving expressivity impossible", "Evidence flags and unadjusted diagnostic CIs are not strict causal attribution", ], } def _validate(rows, scene_ids, *, plan=None, observation="query_id"): identities = set() for row in rows: identity = (row_key(row), row["scene_id"], row["role"], row[observation]) if identity in identities: raise ValueError("Duplicate raw observation") identities.add(identity) if row["scene_id"] not in scene_ids: raise ValueError("Unknown or protected scene in raw") if plan is not None: expected = {(s["key"], s["scene_id"]) for s in plan} actual = {(r["key"], r["scene_id"]) for r in rows if r["method"] == "direct"} if actual != expected: raise ValueError("Raw does not cover exactly the planned states") def analyze( baseline_rows, query_rows, context_rows, oracle_rows, summaries, expected_scene_ids, *, plan=None, manifest=None, draws=10000, seed=20260927, ): """Return seven JSON-ready artifacts; all inputs are saved raw observations.""" scene_ids = sorted(expected_scene_ids) if len(set(scene_ids)) != len(scene_ids) or not scene_ids: raise ValueError("Unique nonempty scene roster required") states = None if plan is None else plan["states"] if states is not None and manifest is None: raise ValueError("A state plan requires the locked scene manifest") if states is not None and set(summaries) != {s["key"] for s in states}: raise ValueError("Every planned state must have a saved optimization summary") baseline_identities = {(r["scene_id"], r["method"], r["query_id"]) for r in baseline_rows} if len(baseline_identities) != len(baseline_rows): raise ValueError("Duplicate baseline observation") if any(r["method"] not in {"A", "B", "anchor", "prior"} for r in baseline_rows): raise ValueError("Unknown baseline method") query_ids = defaultdict(set) for row in baseline_rows: query_ids[row["scene_id"]].add(row["query_id"]) if sorted(query_ids) != scene_ids: raise ValueError("Baseline must cover exactly the exposed scene roster") expected_baseline = { (scene, role, fid) for scene in scene_ids for role in ("A", "B", "anchor", "prior") for fid in query_ids[scene] } if baseline_identities != expected_baseline: raise ValueError("Every baseline role must contain all locked queries") if manifest is not None: records = {r["scene_id"]: r for r in manifest["scenes"]} if sorted(records) != scene_ids or set(scene_ids) & set( manifest["FINAL_HOLDOUT_PROHIBITED"] ): raise ValueError("Manifest roster must match exposed scenes without holdout") if any( query_ids[scene] != set(records[scene]["roles"]["primary_query"]) for scene in scene_ids ): raise ValueError("Queries disagree with locked manifest") expected_context = set() if states is None: permitted = { (row_key(r), r["scene_id"], r["role"]) for r in query_rows if r["method"] == "direct" } else: permitted = { (row_key({**s, "method": "direct"}), s["scene_id"], s["role"]) for s in states if s["phase"] == "context" } for key, scene, role in permitted: frames = records[scene]["roles"]["context_a" if role == "A" else "context_b"] expected_context.update((key, scene, role, fid) for fid in frames) actual_context = { (row_key(r), r["scene_id"], r["role"], r["frame_id"]) for r in context_rows } if actual_context != expected_context: raise ValueError( "Context results must cover every planned role and locked frame exactly" ) if states is not None: expected_keys = { (s["key"], s["scene_id"], s["role"]) for s in states if s["phase"] == "context" } actual_keys = {(r["key"], r["scene_id"], r["role"]) for r in context_rows} if actual_keys != expected_keys: raise ValueError("Context evaluation state keys do not match the plan") for rows in (query_rows, oracle_rows): role_ids = defaultdict(set) for row in rows: role_ids[row_key(row), row["scene_id"], row["role"]].add(row["query_id"]) if any(ids != query_ids[scene] for (_, scene, _), ids in role_ids.items()): raise ValueError("Every state/control must score exactly the same locked queries") if states is not None: for rows, phase in ((query_rows, "context"), (oracle_rows, "oracle")): expected_roles = defaultdict(set) actual_roles = defaultdict(set) for spec in states: if spec["phase"] == phase: expected_roles[row_key({**spec, "method": "direct"}), spec["scene_id"]].add( spec["role"] ) for row in rows: if row["method"] == "direct": actual_roles[row_key(row), row["scene_id"]].add(row["role"]) if actual_roles != expected_roles: raise ValueError("Incomplete A/B roles in planned states") _validate( query_rows, scene_ids, plan=None if states is None else [s for s in states if s["phase"] == "context"], ) _validate( oracle_rows, scene_ids, plan=None if states is None else [s for s in states if s["phase"] == "oracle"], ) _validate(context_rows, scene_ids, observation="frame_id") if any(r["track"] == "QUERY_ORACLE" for r in query_rows) or any( r["track"] != "QUERY_ORACLE" for r in oracle_rows ): raise ValueError("Context and privileged oracle blocks must be separate") grouped, contexts = defaultdict(list), defaultdict(list) for row in query_rows + oracle_rows: grouped[row_key(row)].append(row) for row in context_rows: contexts[row_key(row)].append(row) baseline_groups = defaultdict(list) for row in baseline_rows: role = row["method"] name = "CARRIER" if role in ("A", "B") else role.upper() baseline_groups[name].append({**row, "role": role}) for name in ("CARRIER", "ANCHOR", "PRIOR"): if name not in baseline_groups: raise ValueError("Missing carrier/anchor/prior baseline") # Each control and baseline must retain the locked A/B roles as well as query IDs. for key, rows in grouped.items(): roles = defaultdict(set) for row in rows: roles[row["scene_id"]].add(row["role"]) expected = ( {"joint_query"} if key.startswith("QUERY_ORACLE|") and CURRENT in key else {"A", "B"} ) if any(value != expected for value in roles.values()): raise ValueError("Missing or unexpected context roles") for name, rows in baseline_groups.items(): if name == "CARRIER": for scene in scene_ids: if {r["role"] for r in rows if r["scene_id"] == scene} != {"A", "B"}: raise ValueError("Missing carrier A/B role") groups = {} for key, rows in {**grouped, **baseline_groups}.items(): metrics = {} available = METRICS + tuple(k for k in GEOMETRY if all(k in r for r in rows)) for metric in available: values = scene_values(rows, metric) if sorted(values) != scene_ids: raise ValueError("Every method must cover every scene") metrics[metric] = describe(values, draws=draws, seed=seed) groups[key] = { "metrics": metrics, "n_rows": len(rows), "scientific_role": "DIAGNOSTIC_ORACLE" if key.startswith("QUERY_ORACLE|") else "CONTEXT_ONLY" if "|" in key else "FROZEN_CARRIER_BASELINE", } if key in grouped: groups[key]["spec"] = { k: rows[0][k] for k in ("track", "grid", "samples", "bounds_mode", "method") } groups[key]["render_seconds_total"] = sum(r.get("seconds", 0) for r in rows) if key in contexts: groups[key]["context_metrics"] = { metric: describe(scene_values(contexts[key], metric), draws=draws, seed=seed) for metric in METRICS } comparisons = {} def contrast(name, left, right, metric="depth_absrel", improvement=True): comparisons[name] = paired( groups[left]["metrics"][metric]["per_scene"], groups[right]["metrics"][metric]["per_scene"], draws=draws, seed=seed, improvement=improvement, ) comparisons[name]["definition"] = f"{left} - {right} ({metric})" comparisons[name]["positive_means"] = "improvement" if improvement else "larger_gap" for track in ("RGBD", "RGB_ONLY"): for grid in (8, 16, 32): key = group_key(track, grid) contrast(f"capacity_gap_{track}_g{grid}", "CARRIER", key) contrast(f"anchor_gap_{track}_g{grid}", "ANCHOR", key) contrast(f"direct_minus_carrier_{track}_g{grid}", key, "CARRIER", improvement=False) contrast(f"context_{track}_minus_oracle_g{grid}", key, group_key("QUERY_ORACLE", grid)) for a, b in ((8, 16), (16, 32)): contrast(f"resolution_{track}_{a}_to_{b}", group_key(track, a), group_key(track, b)) contrast(f"bounds_gain_{track}", group_key(track), group_key(track, bounds=ALTERNATIVE)) for method in ( "wrong_scene", "spatial_shuffle", "density_only", "color_only", "zero_density_color", ): contrast( f"control_damage_{track}_{method}", group_key(track, method=method), group_key(track), ) contrast( "bounds_gain_QUERY_ORACLE", group_key("QUERY_ORACLE"), group_key("QUERY_ORACLE", bounds=ALTERNATIVE), ) for grid in (8, 16): contrast( f"renderer_RGBD_g{grid}_64_to_128", group_key("RGBD", grid), group_key("RGBD", grid, 128), ) for group in groups.values(): if "context_metrics" not in group: continue group["generalization_gap"] = { metric: paired( group["metrics"][metric]["per_scene"], group["context_metrics"][metric]["per_scene"], draws=draws, seed=seed, improvement=False, ) for metric in ("depth_absrel", "depth_rmse", "rgb_mse") } metric_comparisons = {} for track in ("RGBD", "RGB_ONLY"): for grid in (8, 16, 32): key = group_key(track, grid) metric_comparisons[key] = {} for metric in METRICS: stats = paired( groups[key]["metrics"][metric]["per_scene"], groups["CARRIER"]["metrics"][metric]["per_scene"], draws=draws, seed=seed, improvement=False, ) if metric in ("depth_absrel", "depth_rmse", "rgb_mse"): stats["improved_tied_worse"] = [ stats["negative"], stats["tied"], stats["positive"], ] stats["better_direction"] = "negative" elif metric in ("depth_delta1", "rgb_ssim"): stats["improved_tied_worse"] = [ stats["positive"], stats["tied"], stats["negative"], ] stats["better_direction"] = "positive" else: stats["better_direction"] = "not_intrinsically_task_quality" stats["definition"] = f"{key} - CARRIER ({metric})" metric_comparisons[key][metric] = stats classification = classify(groups, comparisons) curves, costs = {}, defaultdict(list) specs = {s["key"]: s for s in states} if states is not None else {} for key, summary in sorted(summaries.items()): checks = summary["full_objective_checkpoints"] last = checks[-3:] trend = ( float( np.polyfit([v["step"] for v in last], [v["context_objective"] for v in last], 1)[0] ) if len(last) > 1 else None ) curves[key] = { **summary, "last3_objective_slope_per_step": trend, "convergence_claim": "NOT_ESTABLISHED_BY_FIXED_BUDGET", } if key in specs: spec = specs[key] group = group_key(spec["track"], spec["grid"], spec["samples"], spec["bounds_mode"]) costs[group].append(summary) for key, rows in costs.items(): groups[key]["optimization_cost"] = { "n_states": len(rows), "seconds_total": sum(r["seconds"] for r in rows), "seconds_mean": float(np.mean([r["seconds"] for r in rows])), "parameter_count_per_state": sorted({r["parameter_count"] for r in rows}), "peak_cuda_allocated_bytes": max( (r.get("peak_cuda_allocated_bytes") or 0) for r in rows ), "peak_cuda_reserved_bytes": max((r.get("peak_cuda_reserved_bytes") or 0) for r in rows), "selected_at_budget_boundary": sum( r["final_selected_at_budget_boundary"] for r in rows ), } blocks = {"context_only": {}, "diagnostic_oracle": {}, "frozen_carrier": {}} for key, group in groups.items(): block = ( "diagnostic_oracle" if key.startswith("QUERY_ORACLE|") else "context_only" if "|" in key else "frozen_carrier" ) blocks[block][key] = group return { "direct_state_results": { "scene_ids": scene_ids, "n_scenes": len(scene_ids), **blocks, "query_metric_scope": "All GT-valid depth pixels; no prediction-derived masking", "coverage_definition": "opacity>1e-6, not true scene visibility", }, "capacity_analysis": { "classification": classification, "comparisons": comparisons, "direct_minus_carrier_all_metrics": metric_comparisons, "generalization": { k: g["generalization_gap"] for k, g in groups.items() if "generalization_gap" in g }, }, "resolution_analysis": { k: v for k, v in comparisons.items() if k.startswith("resolution_") }, "renderer_capacity_analysis": { k: v for k, v in comparisons.items() if k.startswith("renderer_") }, "bootstrap_results": { "unit": "scene; first average queries within role then roles A/B", "draws": draws, "seed": seed, "comparisons": comparisons, }, "optimization_curves": curves, "bounds_analysis": {k: v for k, v in comparisons.items() if k.startswith("bounds_")}, }